Witchcraft in Connecticut

The Year: 1647

Image: Witchcraft Trial

In 1642, witchcraft became punishable by death in the Connecticut Colony. This capital offense was backed by references to the King James version of the Bible: Exodus (22:18) says, Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live. And Leviticus (20:27) says, A man also or woman that hath a familiar spirit, or that is a wizard, shall surely be put to death: they shall stone them with stones: their blood (shall be) upon them.

Belief in witchcraft was common in seventeenth-century New England. The infamous witchcraft trials at Salem in 1692 are well known, but if you exclude those, ninety-three complaints of witchcraft were made in New England between 1638 and 1697—forty-three in Connecticut and fifty in Massachusetts, which was much more heavily populated.

Witchcraft was defined as giving entertainment to Satan. The first known witchcraft trial in North America and the first execution for witchcraft took place in Connecticut in 1647. Eleven of the sixteen persons executed for the crime of witchcraft in New England prior to 1692 lived in Connecticut. They were:

  • Alse Young of Windsor hanged in 1647
  • Mary Johnson of Wethersfield executed in 1648
  • Joan and John Carrington of Wethersfield killed in 1651
  • Goodwife Bassett of Fairfield hung in 1651
  • Goodwife Knapp of Fairfield hung in 1653
  • Lydia Gilbert of Windsor killed in 1654
  • Rebecca and Nathaniel Greensmith of Hartford killed in 1662
  • Mary Sanford of Hartford killed in 1662
  • Mary Barnes of Farmington hanged in 1663

The Water Test
Suspected witches were sometimes dropped into a body of water to determine if they possessed evil spirits. If she sank, she was innocent. If she floated, she was guilty because the pure water had cast out her evil spirit.

Witches were believed to have superhuman powers to harm other people or to lure them into a compact with the devil. They were generally charged with giving themselves to the devil or losing their fear of God. Sometimes, a witch would be identified through witch marks seen on her body. Accusers tried to force witnesses to testify against the accused.

The Accusation
A formal complaint started the process. Then local magistrates collected evidence, usually depositions from witnesses and an examination of the accused. Torture was a favorite method of extracting confessions—because people would say almost anything to get the pain to stop. To confess to witchcraft was to earn a life sentence in jail, and to deny the charge often resulted in a death sentence.

The information collected by the magistrates was forwarded to the higher courts, which referred the case to a grand jury for indictment. Full consideration was given to written evidence and testimony by witnesses. If indicted, the case went to a jury trial. The governor’s assistant served as prosecutor, and shaped the jury’s understanding of the case. Once all of the evidence was presented, the jury delivered its verdict and the magistrate imposed the sentence. If the jury returned a verdict with which the magistrate disagreed, he could overturn it.

By the mid-1660s, Connecticut Governor John Winthrop Jr. began to express concern about executing witches, and public sentiment eventually began to turn against the practice. Between 1653 and 1697, more than thirty other residents of the Colony were accused of being witches. They either fled prosecution, were acquitted, or were found guilty of lesser crimes. None of these were executed.

In Connecticut, witchcraft was last listed as a capital crime in 1715. The crime of witchcraft disappeared from the list of capital crimes when the laws were next issued in 1750.

Historians can’t say exactly what caused the witchcraft trials, but many believe that fear was the primary cause. The colonists held strong religious beliefs, and after years of fighting Native Americans, floods, and epidemics, may have been looking for someone or something to blame for their hardships.

Alse Young
Witches and Witchcraft
Connecticut Witch Trials
The Capital Crime Was Witchcraft

Leave a Reply